Posts

Showing posts with the label Polarization

Start here

Shreds of a bizarre world is not a diary you have to swallow newest-first. It’s an archive of scenes, satire, and arguments. Start where you’re interested:

All posts by date are still below. Better to enter through a door, though.

Sinister design - part four: the allegory


You can read part three at this link.

In the previous installments I talked about a whirlpool: the mechanism that sucks us in when we pick a side on crises we can't verify. To make this clearer, I'll use a movie allegory — and no, I'm not saying we live in a simulation: I'm only using the film as an example.

Nearly everyone has seen "The Matrix," the wonderful trilogy starring Keanu Reeves. And plenty of people came out of it feeling exhilarated: "It's a smart story, I understood it, so I must be smart too." They think.

And in fact the result looks encouraging. But then you look at them, and it becomes clear they haven't picked up on all the symbolic sides of it, the metaphorical layers that make it relevant even without the technological apocalypse. They stopped at the plot about sentient machines that drain humans of their energy while keeping them living in a simulated dream, the matrix itself. They can't put two and two together, can't connect those blessed dots.

So let's spell out the allegory. In our reality, the "machines" can be represented by politics and the media. The dreams — the film's matrix — are the polarized issues that politics and the media hand to citizens. And the energy being drained is that of the individuals who fall for the trick and devote themselves, heart and soul, to fueling the mechanism: that's the whirlpool.

Let's look at a few examples from the string of polarizing issues pushed on the masses in recent years. Did we dig in, helmet on and bayonet fixed, taking a position (any position) on the various disputes over the pandemic? We got sucked in. Did we pick a side on the Russia-Ukraine war? We're sinking toward the bottom. Did we pick a side on the Palestine-Israel question? It's already too late. Did we pick a side on the US-Iran war? Same story.

And you can be sure that when interest in the crisis of the moment fades, politics and the media will supply us with new ones. As I said before, the content isn't the point. The goal is distraction, splitting public opinion. Divide et impera.

Okay, take some time to think it over. Then, if you like, go ahead and rewatch the film. Maybe this time the parallel will be clearer.

You can find the other installments of the "Sinister design" saga by following this link.

Drafted from Italian with Blog Translator, then revised by me.

Sinister design - part two


You can read part one at this link. 

I'd like to explain more clearly how I think the manipulation of the masses works through polarization on "distant" issues, the ones citizens have no way of verifying directly.

You have to step back from the polarized issues themselves and shift the lens to those with an interest in selecting, fueling and steering them: politics and the media. What matters isn't getting one side or the other to win, but splitting public opinion into opposing factions. Factions that waste time and energy backing one bloc or the other, without, as I said, being able to verify anything.

Whoever picks a side has already been sucked into the whirlpool. They believe the level they've placed themselves on is the one tied to reality, where they would have free choice, and they blindly trust the sources of information they feed on. Of course, this holds for every faction. Everyone is convinced they're right. In reality they're all wrong, not so much about the merits of the issues, but for having swallowed the bait and taken a position at all.

Meanwhile, with the "divide et impera" mode switched on this way, the field is left wide open on the "near" problems, the ones citizens could actually verify and keep in check, but which nobody has the time or the inclination to poke their nose into, given the full-time effort they pour, fruitlessly, into the "distant" crises.

In short, traps are being set for us. Avoiding them would be very easy; all it would take is resisting the temptation to take sides on matters that can't be verified anyway. But we can't resist the temptation. We put our foot in the trap, we waste our energy thrashing about and pummeling one another like Manzoni's capons, pecking at each other on the way. Meanwhile, somebody cleans out our house undisturbed.

No hidden plan is needed: the mechanism just has to work. And it works! Those who feed it profit. But the suckers are always us.

You can find the other installments of the "Sinister design" saga at this link.

Drafted from Italian with Blog Translator, then revised by me.

Sinister design


Has anyone noticed that citizens almost never take each other on over issues in their own building, neighborhood, or town — those that affect them directly and that they can see and touch — and instead argue almost exclusively over distant crises like Israel-Palestine, Russia-Ukraine, or US-Iran — on which they have thirdhand information (at best) and about as much power to intervene as the moves in a Christmas game of Risk?
Are they doing it out of altruism? Let's not go there: that doesn't work on me. The amount of ego and the level of certainty (not to mention the bullshit hackery) that so many people pour into their rants leave no room for a charitable reading of their attitude.

I have a suspicion — and no, I'm not talking about secret lodges. I mean something we can all observe every day: politics and the media pushing our attention toward distant crises. Doesn't it occur to you that this might be deliberate, to keep us away from the problems that affect us directly and where we'd have both the power to act and the right to make demands, diverting our attention and energy onto topics that are out of our reach and where we have no room to maneuver?
The motto seems to be this: "Go ahead and worry about faraway crises, because while you're distracted, we're fucking you over good at home." There's no need to resort to cabals, conspiracies, or plots: all it takes is for the mechanism to work — and it does work, even if few people notice the effect.

But I'm probably exaggerating, of course. Let's just keep doing what we've always done. We'll surely manage to stop the wars on other continents, while back home our leaders take care of our needs in the best and most dispassionate way. We're doing just great.

You can find the other installments of the "Sinister design" saga at this link.

Drafted from Italian with Blog Translator, then revised by me.

Borrowing from abstract art



These are two very famous abstract paintings.
I'm not an art expert and I'm not gonna talk about art here. Yet I find art an extremely good tool to visually convey counterintuitive ideas, even those that have nothing to do with the artworks themselves.
I will use Kandinsky's "Composition VII" (the first one) to represent reality. Rothko's "No. 4, two dominants" (the second one) on the other hand can stand for a polarized simplification of that same reality.
Now imagine trying to understand the complexity inherent in the first representation by using the second one as a model. Ridiculous, right?
Even worse is thinking you can not only understand but manipulate complex reality using the polarized model.
Well, as absurd as it may seem, that is what many of us do every day, in any field.
I think this is one of the most tragic aspects of our times.